BusinessWeekly DebriefCold Traffic Experiment
Cold Traffic Experiment, Week 3: 13 people showed up, and I forgot my own advice

Last week, I set three goals for the week of my first masterclass, Fix Your Follow-Up:
- Get 25 to 50% of registrants to actually show up.
- Get at least one person to join the priority waitlist for Build Your Sales System.
- Improve my email click-through rate.
Spoiler: I checked off one out of three, but I learned a lot!
So here’s week three: what happened, what I almost did next, and the moment I realized I wasn’t following my own advice.
This week’s experiment
Week one was about getting strangers onto my email list. ✅
Week two was about getting those strangers to take a next step with me. ✅ (sort of)
Week three was the real test: would people actually show up for an hour, stay, and want more?
Goal 1: Did people show up?
27 people registered. 13 showed up live. That’s 48%. Right at the top of my 25 to 50% goal. ✅
But the more interesting number is who showed up.
| Registered | Showed up | Show rate | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warm (my existing email list) | 12 | 8 | 67% |
| Cold (came in through the ads) | 15 | 5 | 33% |
| Total | 27 | 13 | 48% |
Warm people showed up at twice the rate of cold people. Not a surprise, but it’s good to see it in black and white. Trust shows up. Literally.
Still, five complete strangers gave me an hour of their workday. That’s a win, and I appreciate them.
Did they stay?
This was my biggest fear going in. Would people drop off after ten minutes?
They didn’t. 12 of the 13 people stayed for the full hour. The one person who left early left around the halfway mark, and they reached out afterwards about a consulting engagement. Halfway through and a new opportunity? I’ll call that a win!
And two people stayed after the masterclass ended to ask questions about their own businesses. One of them stayed for 15 minutes beyond the end of the masterclass. If people want to stay, I’ll provide value all day long.
What people said in the chat
For a small group, the chat was on fire with engagement. This makes facilitating way more rewarding. A few highlights from the chat include:
- “Sometimes it is not even an objection but rather a fear of misunderstanding.”
- “I started the day with 202 follow-up calls on my list.” (That one got a 😮 from someone else.)
- “How do you say ‘do you have any objections?’ What is the correct wording?”
- “What if the client doesn’t do their part of the next step?”
And when I asked for their biggest takeaway at the end, here’s what people said:
- “Always have a date and time set for the follow-up.”
- “Qualify the potential client.”
- “Timing the follow-up before the call ends.”
- “Get more clarity from the client and be clearer with them.”
- “Remembering BANT again!”
- “I took 5 pages of notes!!”
Those takeaways are almost word-for-word the three causes of follow-up frustration that I taught: qualification, unanswered questions, and no clear next step. When people can repeat the lesson back to you in their own words, it landed. And well, as a facilitator, that’s our goal!
Goal 2: Did anyone join the priority waitlist?
No. ❌
Zero enrollments. Zero waitlist sign-ups from the masterclass.
To be fair, I’d decided on the day to treat this first one as a dry run. I wanted to test the content, so I ended with a soft invitation to join a priority waitlist using an on-screen QR code rather than presenting the full offer. But I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t hoping for at least one waitlist sign-up.
Hold that thought. It might be the most useful number in this whole post.
The replay page
I didn’t want to send people a Zoom link and call it a replay. I wanted something people would actually use. So with my AI co-creator (Claude), I built a private replay page on my website.

Above: the replay page. Every tick on the play bar is a chapter. Hover to see its name, click to jump there.
- 12 chapters, from “Welcome: is this masterclass for you?” to “Stop adding to your list: 3 end-of-call questions.” Each one is a marker right on the play bar.
- A “Jump to a section” list beside the video, so you can skim the whole hour at a glance.
- A participant guide pop-up in the first two minutes, so people grab the workbook before they start.
- A waitlist pop-up in the last minute, right when I talk about what’s next.

The chapters came from the transcript of the recording. Claude found the natural breaks, I named them in my own words, and we built the player together. It took an hour, not a week.
And because so many people watch replays in the car or between calls, it works on a phone too.

The urge to build a new bridge
The day after the masterclass, I got the itch. Zero waitlist sign-ups? Clearly I needed a new ad campaign. A new angle, new creative, a new lead form. A whole new bridge to get people across.
And I started building it. I even had a good angle: endless follow-up is a symptom of a missing system. Ads drafted, lead form drafted, creative drafted.
Then I decided to sleep on it.
When I woke up, I looked at the numbers again. And the numbers said something different. The ads aren’t the problem. They bring in leads at around two dollars each, every single day. My challenge isn’t getting people in the door. It’s what happens after they walk through it.
The next step wasn’t to test a new campaign. The next step is to see if I can warm up the people coming into my world through cold Meta ads on the current campaign that is converting at a phenomenal cost per lead.
Goal 3: Did my email clicks improve?
Not yet. ❌ And this is where it all clicked for me (pun intended).
| Opened | Clicked | |
|---|---|---|
| The email that delivers the free guide | 69% | 38% |
| My four-email welcome series (invites people to the masterclass) | 35% | 1% |
| Masterclass invites to people who downloaded the guide | 38 to 44% | 1 to 3% |
| My personal masterclass invite to my warm list | 61% | 19% |
People want the guide. Almost four in ten click to get it. Then I ask them to give me an hour of their day, and the clicks fall to about one in a hundred.
My warm list? One in five clicked.
A quick note if you’re looking at your own email numbers: open rates are inflated these days, because Apple Mail “opens” emails on people’s behalf to protect their privacy. Clicks are the honest number. Watch the clicks.
So a new ad campaign would have just poured more people into the same leaky bucket. I shelved it.
Here’s what I think is really going on. I’m asking for an hour of someone’s time, and they have no idea who I am. My ads don’t even show my face. Even if they clicked through to my Instagram, I’d still be a stranger. That’s a big ask for someone who met me five minutes ago.
Did I follow my own advice? (LOL)
What I teach my clients, over and over, is to slow down. Don’t rush to the close. Qualify. Uncover the questions they haven’t asked yet. Earn the next step.
And what did I do? Someone downloads a free guide from a stranger on Facebook, and within a few days I’m asking them to block off an hour of their workday.
That’s the follow-up equivalent of proposing on the first date.
The warm people who showed up already trusted me. The cold people hadn’t had a chance to get to know me yet. I was asking for the big yes before I’d earned any of the small ones.
The ads: an experiment, not a strategy (yet)
Here are the numbers from my Meta lead ads for The Follow-Up Formula:
| Last 7 days | Since launch (Oct 25 to Nov 15) | |
|---|---|---|
| Spent | $268.39 | $734.00 |
| New leads | 132 | 440 |
| Average cost per lead | about $2.03 | about $1.67 |
The cost per lead crept up this week, but at about two dollars a lead, nothing concerning.
I want to be clear about what these ads are: a 30-day experiment. And so far the finding is simple. I can get people in the door at a low cost. But they are cold. Cold, cold, cold.
Ads take runway. Turning a stranger into a client takes time, and I’m only three weeks in.
Nerd alert 🤓: the $96 ad
Remember the retargeting ad from last week? The one that only shows to people who’ve already shown interest, like visiting my website?
It spent $95.83 in total and brought in 5 masterclass registrations, at $19.17 each. Last week I said my target was somewhere between $8 and $20 per registration. It landed inside that range.
Only one of those five retargeting people attended, and they are the one who reached out about a consulting engagement.
Compare that with the guide ads. I’ve spent $734 on them, and 14 people who downloaded the guide registered for the masterclass. That’s about $52 per registration, down from about $80 last week. Better, but still a long way from $19.
My hypothesis from last week is holding up: people who click through to my website and fill in a form are warmer than people who tap an instant form inside Facebook.
The test for this week: a free mini-series
So instead of a new ad campaign, I’m building a free video mini-series. It’s five short lessons by email, a day or two apart, or you can binge them Netflix-style if you’d rather.
It’s a much smaller ask than an hour on Zoom. A few minutes at a time, on your schedule, and you get to know me before I ask for anything bigger.
- Intro: Who I am, why I’m qualified to teach this, and what’s in it for you.
- Lesson 1: Endless follow-up is a symptom of a missing system.
- Lesson 2: Qualify first.
- Lesson 3: The questions they’re not asking you.
- Lesson 4: Own the next step.
- Wrap-up: What changes when you have a real system, and an invitation to join the waitlist for Build Your Sales System.
Each lesson gives you the what and the why, plus one small quick win you can use on your next call. It doesn’t give away the full how. That’s what the program is for.
And since I already taught all of this live, most of the lessons are cut straight from the masterclass recording, with a short new intro for each. No reinventing the wheel.
Here’s how it fits into the experiment:
- Every new lead who downloads the guide will go straight into the mini-series.
- Everyone already in, or finished with, my welcome series gets added to the mini-series as well.
Five minutes, not sixty. Let people get to know me before I ask for the big yes.
And to be clear, I’m not expecting the mini-series to fill my December program. It’s a longer game: a better first few weeks for every new person who comes in through Meta, leading with value before making a bigger ask.
It goes back to a sales principle I talk about all the time. People do business with people, usually people they can relate to and trust. A cold ad can’t build that. A few short videos might.
What’s next
One goal above everything else this week: fill the first group of Build Your Sales System, starting December 1. My target is 5 to 10 people. This is going to be my beta group launch, and I’m going to make it happen.
Here’s how:
- Direct outreach is my main path to revenue. Personal conversations with the people who showed up, the people who stayed after to ask questions, and the people who lead teams. That’s where the trust already is, and that’s where this first group will come from.
- The mini-series goes live for every new lead, and for everyone who’s been through my welcome series.
- The ads keep running until November 25. That’s the 30-day mark. Then I’ll look at a full month of data and decide what role ads play from here.
Funny enough, that’s exactly the order I’d tell a client to work in. Start with the people who already know you. Build the system for strangers alongside it, not instead of it.
Come back next week to see how it went.
If you’re running your own experiment
Here’s what week three taught me:
- Show-up rate is about trust, not reminders. My reminder emails were opened by 74 to 92% of registrants. Reminders weren’t the gap. The relationship was.
- When people stay, the content works. 12 of 13 stayed the full hour. The masterclass isn’t the problem. The timing of the ask is.
- Don’t fix what isn’t broken. My instinct was to build new ads. The data said the ads were fine. Sleeping on it saved me a week and a few hundred dollars.
- Watch clicks, not opens. Opens make you feel good. Clicks tell you the truth.
- Ads buy attention, not trust. Cheap leads are still cold leads. Revenue this month comes from relationships.
- Practise what you preach. Slow down. Earn the small yeses. That goes for your sales process, and apparently for mine too.
Want to fix your follow-up with me? Join the next free masterclass. Or grab The Follow-Up Formula, the same guide everyone’s downloading.
